Quarterbacks
- Carson Palmer – Cincinnati Bengals (Winston)
- Michael Vick – Atlanta Falcons (Dave S.)
- Eli Manning – New York Giants (Dave S.)
- Peyton Manning – Indianapolis Colts (Dave H.)
- Tom Brady – New England Patriots (Brian)
- Drew Brees – San Diego Chargers (Rob)
- Marc Bulger – St. Louis Rams (Jason)
- Matt Hasselbeck – Seattle Seahawks (Al)
Running Backs
- Ladanian Tomlinson – San Diego Chargers (Winston)
- Shawn Alexander – Seattle Seahawks (Winston)
- Willis McGahee – Buffalo Bills (Dave S.)
- Warrick Dunn – Atlanta Falcons (Mike)
- Larry Johnson – Kansas City Chiefs (Jeremy)
- Lamont Jordan – Oakland Raiders (Jeremy)
- Carnell Williams – Tampa Bay Buccaneers (Dave H.)
- Edgerrin James – Indianapolis Colts (Brian)
- Steven Jackson – St. Louis Rams (Rob)
- Ronnie Brown – Miami Dolphis (Jason)
- Brian Westbrook – Philadelphia Eagles (Al)
Wide Receivers
- Torry Holt – St. Louis Rams (Winston)
- Randy Moss – Oakland Raiders (Dave S.)
- T.J. Houshmandzadeh – Cincinatti Bengals (Mike)
- David Givens – New England Patriots (Mike)
- Larry Fitzgerald – Arizona Cardinals (Jeremy)
- Terrell Owens – Philadelphia Eagles (Jeremy)
- Santana Moss – Washington Redskins (Brian)
- Darrell Jackson – Seattle Seahawks (Al)
- Steve Smith – Carolina Panthers (Rob)
- Marvin Harrison – Indianapolis Colts (Rob)
- Rod Smith – Denver Broncos (Jason)
- Keyshawn Johnson – Dallas Cowboys (Jason)
Tight Ends
- Jeremy Shockey – New York Giants (Winston)
- Alge Crumpler – Atlanta Falcons (Dave S.)
- Randy McMichael – Miami Dolphins (Mike)
- Antonio Gates – San Diego Chargers (Jeremy)
- Jason Witten – Dallas Cowboys (Jason)
- Tony Gonzalez – Kansas City Chiefs (Al)
- Chris Cooley – Washington Redskins (Brian)
Kickers
No kickers were kept.
Team Defenses
- New York Giants – New York Giants (Rob)
- Chicago – Chicago Bears (Al)
Individual Defenders
- Mike Vrabel – New England Patriots (Mike)
- Keith Bulluck – Tennessee Titans (Brian)