Catcher
- Jorge Posada – New York Yankees (Winston)
- Brian McCann – Atlanta Braves (Al)
First Base
- Mark Teixeira – Atlanta Braves (Winston)
- Raul Ibanez – Seattle Mariners (Al)
- James Loney – Los Angeles Dodgers (Al)
Second Base
- Chone Figgins – Anaheim Angels (Winston)
- Dustin Pedroia – Boston Red Sox (Winston)
Third Base
- Chone Figgins – Anaheim Angels (Winston)
- Garrett Atkins – Colorado Rockies (Al)
Shortstop
- Dustin Pedroia – Boston Red Sox (Winston)
- Jimmy Rollins – Philadelphia Phillies (Al)
- Hanley Ramirez – Florida Marlins (Winston)
Outfield
- Chone Figgins – Anaheim Angels (Winston)
- Bobby Abreu – Philadelphia Phillies (Al)
- Raul Ibanez – Seattle Mariners (Al)
- Hideki Matsui – New York Yankees (Winston)
- Manny Ramirez – Boston Red Sox (Winston)
Util
No util's were kept.
Starting Pitchers
- Brandon Webb – Arizona Diamondbacks (Winston)
- Roy Halladay – Toronto Blue Jays (Winston)
- Brad Penny – Los Angeles Dodgers (Al)
- Ryan Dempster – Chicago Cubs (Al)
- Jered Weaver – Anaheim Angels (Winston)
Relief Pitchers
- Heath Bell – San Diego Padres (Winston)
- Joba Chamberlain – New York Yankees (Winston)
- Ryan Dempster – Chicago Cubs (Al)
- Bobby Jenks – Chicago White Sox (Al)