Catcher
- Jorge Posada – New York Yankees (Winston)
- Joe Mauer – Minnesota Twins (Bill)
- Victor Martinez – Cleveland Indians (Chris)
- Brian McCann – Atlanta Braves (Al)
- Kenji Johima – Seattle Mariners (Shane)
First Base
- Mark Teixeira – Texas Rangers (Winston)
- Lance Berkman – Houston Astors (Bill)
- Jim Thome – Philadelphia Phillies (Shane)
- Nick Swisher – Oakland Athletics (Rob)
- Paul Konerko – Chicago White Sox (Al)
- David Ortiz – Boston Red Sox (Dave S.)
- Albert Pujols – St. Louis Cardinals (Rob)
- Chase Utley – Philadelphia Phillies (Rob)
- Carlos Delgado – Florida Marlins (Jeremy)
- Adam LaRoche – Atlanta Braves (Winston)
- Ryan Howard – Philadelphia Phillies (Chris)
- Howie Kendrick – Anaheim Angels (Chris)
- Justin Morneau – Minnesota Twins (Dave S.)
Second Base
- Bill Hall – Milwaukee Brewers (Al)
- Alfonso Soriano – Texas Rangers (Bill)
- Jose Reyes – New York Metes (Dave S.)
- Chase Utley – Philadelphia Phillies (Rob)
- Jose Vidro – Washington Nationals (Mike)
- Brian Roberts – Baltimore Orioles (Dave S.)
- Rickie Weeks – Milwaukee Brewers (Jeremy)
- Dan Uggla – Florida Marlins (Bill)
- Freddy Sanchez – Pittsburgh Pirates (Mike)
- Howie Kendrick – Anaheim Angels (Chris)
Third Base
- Chone Figgins – Anaheim Angels (Winston)
- Bill Hall – Milwaukee Brewers (Al)
- Aramis Ramirez – Chicaco Cubs (Shane)
- Chipper Jones – Atlanta Braves (Chris)
- Alex Rodriguez – New York Yankees (Jeremy)
- Freddy Sanchez – Pittsburgh Pirates (Mike)
- Edwin Encarnación – Cincinnati Reds (Shane)
- Garrett Atkins – Colorado Rockies (Al)
Shortstop
- Bill Hall – Milwaukee Brewers (Al)
- Miguel Tejada – Baltimore Orioles (Bill)
- Carlos Guillen – Detroit Tigers (Mike)
- Jose Reyes – New York Metes (Dave S.)
- Derek Jeter – New York Yankees (Jeremy)
- Jimmy Rollins – Philadelphia Phillies (Al)
- Michael Young – Texas Rangers (Chris)
- Edgar Renteria – Boston Red Sox (Rob)
- Hanley Ramirez – Florida Marlins (Winston)
- Freddy Sanchez – Pittsburgh Pirates (Mike)
Outfield
- Chone Figgins – Anaheim Angels (Winston)
- Magglio Ordonez – Detroit Tigers (Rob)
- Johnny Damon – Boston Red Sox (Mike)
- Lance Berkman – Houston Astors (Bill)
- Vernon Wells – Toronto Blue Jays (Bill)
- Carlos Lee – Milwaukee Brewers (Jeremy)
- Alfonso Soriano – Texas Rangers (Bill)
- Moises Alou – San Francisco Giants (Shane)
- Bobby Abreu – Philadelphia Phillies (Al)
- Nick Swisher – Oakland Athletics (Rob)
- Carl Crawford – Tampa Bay Devil Rays (Chris)
- Chipper Jones – Atlanta Braves (Chris)
- Andruw Jones – Atlanta Braves (Winston)
- Jeff Francoeur – Atlanta Braves (Dave S.)
- Vladimir Guerrero – Anaheim Angels (Dave S.)
- Hideki Matsui – New York Yankees (Winston)
- Miguel Cabrera – Florida Marlins (Jeremy)
- Manny Ramirez – Boston Red Sox (Winston)
- Grady Sizemore – Cleveland Indians (Chris)
- Coco Crisp – Boston Red Sox (Shane)
- Jason Bay – Pittsburgh Pirates (Chris)
- Delmon Young – Tampa Bay Devil Rays (Bill)
- Austin Kearns – Washington Nationals (Mike)
- Brad Hawpe – Colorado Rockies (Shane)
- Alex Rios – Toronto Blue Jays (Rob)
Util
- Travis Hafner – Cleveland Indians (Bill)
Starting Pitchers
- Derrick Turnbow – Milwaukee Brewers (Mike)
- Brandon Webb – Arizona Diamondbacks (Winston)
- Roy Halladay – Toronto Blue Jays (Winston)
- Jon Garland – Chicago White Sox (Shane)
- Johan Santana – Minnesota Twins (Chris)
- Jason Schimdt – San Francisco Giants (Rob)
- Scott Kazmir – Tampa Bay Devil Rays (Dave S.)
- Mark Prior – Chicago Cubs (Dave S.)
- Carlos Zambrano – Chicago Cubs (Chris)
- John Lackey – Los Angeles Angels (Shane)
- John Smoltz – Atlanta Braves (Dave S.)
- Ben Sheets – Milwaukee Brewers (Dave S.)
- C.C. Sabathia – Cleveland Indians (Rob)
- Mike Mussina – New York Yankees (Rob)
- Roy Oswalt – Houston Astros (Jeremy)
- Chris Carpenter – St. Louis Cadinals (Jeremy)
- Felix Hernandez – Seattle Mariners (Jeremy)
- Dontrelle Willis – Florida Marlins (Al)
- Pedro Martinez – New York Mets (Dave S.)
- Brad Penny – Los Angeles Dodgers (Al)
- Jeremy Bonderman – Detroit Tigers (Rob)
- Jake Peavy – San Diego Padres (Jeremy)
- Justin Verlander – Detroit Tigers (Bill)
- Francisco Liriano – Minnesota Twins (Bill)
- Jered Weaver – Anaheim Angels (Winston)
- Chien-Ming Wang – New York Yankees (Mike)
- Kenny Rogers – Detroit Tigers (Mike)
- Nate Robertson – Detroit Tigers (Mike)
- Jonathan Papelbon – Boston Red Sox (Chris)
- Brett Myers – Philadelphia Phillies (Rob)
- Scott Olsen – Florida Marlins (Al)
- Jason Jennings – Colorado Rockies (Al)
- Anibal Sanchez – Florida Marlins (Al)
Relief Pitchers
- Derrick Turnbow – Milwaukee Brewers (Mike)
- Tom Gordon – New York Yankees (Shane)
- Damaso Marte – Chicago White Sox (Shane)
- Mike Gonzalez – Pittsburgh Pirates (Winston)
- Trevor Hoffman – San Diego Padres (Dave S.)
- Billy Wagner – Philadelphia Phillies (Shane)
- B.J. Ryan – Baltimore Orioles (Bill)
- Huston Street – Oakland Athletics (Bill)
- Brad Lidge – Houston Astros (Mike)
- Chad Cordero – Washington Nationals (Mike)
- John Smoltz – Atlanta Braves (Dave S.)
- Mariano Rivera – New York Yankees (Rob)
- Joe Nathan – Minnesota Twins (Chris)
- Francisco Rodriguez – Anaheim Angels (Jeremy)
- Scott Shields – Anaheim Angels (Jeremy)
- J. J. Putz – Seattle Mariners (Mike)
- Jonathan Papelbon – Boston Red Sox (Chris)
- Bobby Jenks – Chicago White Sox (Al)

